Whether To Replace Or Repair Your Garage Door Opener

When your garage door opener starts acting up or quitting altogether, you will probably be faced with the question of whether to replace or repair your garage door opener. In most cases, it can be a pretty cut-and-dry answer when you consider a few things. We are going to go over when it’s better to repair your garage door opener, and when it is better to replace the opener.

When it is Better to Repair Your Garage Door Opener.

If your garage door is not operating properly, it’s easy to throw your hands up and say “honey, we are going to have to get a new garage door opener motor”. Yet, before you do that, it might be better to have it repaired. Depending on the situation, you may suspect it is the motor, when instead it may be something else. Let’s look at a few of these possibilities.


If the cost of repair is significantly lower than replacement, and the opener has not been prone to frequent breakdowns, repair might be the more economical choice.

Recently Purchased Your Garage Door Opener.

If you have recently purchased your garage door opener, it may still be under warranty, especially if you had a professional garage door company do the work. If this is the case, you can get the garage door opener repaired with little to no cost to you. Even if your garage door opener is outside the warranty time, but still a model that is 5 years or newer, unless you have excessive wear and tear on the motor, chances are it is better to have the garage door opener diagnosed and repaired rather than replacing it.

The Garage Door Opens Only Partway.

When your garage door opens only partway, it’s easy to suspect the motor. This is not always the case. Damaged rollers can also cause the door to stop short of fully opening. Inspect your garage door rollers and the tracks the rollers are in to make sure there are no obstructions or damage to those parts. If that is not the case, the up-limit switch may need to be moved toward the motor unit. This switch is usually a simple touch lever mounted on the end of the track near the motor unit.

The Garage Door Closes Only Partway.

If your garage door only closes partway, your safety sensors are probably out of alignment or going bad. These are near the bottom of the door track on both sides. They are electronic eyes that require a clear line of view between them. Make sure nothing is blocking the line of sight between the two sensors. For more on how to fix your sensors, read Troubleshooting Your Garage Door Safety Sensors

When It Is Better to Replace Your Garage Door Opener.

There are times and situations when it may be better to replace your garage door opener motor. Let’s have a look at a few of these situations.

Frequent Repairs.

If your garage door opener frequently breaks down, requiring constant repairs, it might be more cost-effective in the long run to replace it.

When You Replace Your Garage Door.

If you are getting a new garage door, it may be advisable to get a new opener motor along with it. Your new garage door may have a different weight than your older one and may put more of a strain on your motor, especially if it’s an older model.

Noise Level

Older openers, especially those that operate with a chain drive, can be quite loud. If noise is a concern, replacing your opener with a newer, quieter model like a belt drive or a direct drive might be beneficial.

If You Have an Older Garage Door Opener.

Speaking of having an older model, if your garage door opener is older than 10 years old and is giving you trouble, it would probably be in your best interest to get a new garage door motor instead of repairing the older one you currently have.  The newer ones are going to be quieter than the one you have and have features such as Wi-Fi and a built-in light that your current one does not. In addition, repairs may cost just the same if not more than just getting a new one with better features.

Wanting Newer Features.

As mentioned above, the newer garage door openers have features like Wi-Fi enabled and built-in security light. With Wi-Fi enabled, you’re able to open your garage door with an app on your cell phone. The built-in security light and camera allow you to see who is coming in and out of your garage. If these features are something you do not have but want, it might be worth checking into getting a new garage door opener installed.


When deciding between repair and replacement, consider the age of your opener, the cost of repair versus replacement, and whether the current model meets your needs in terms of safety, security, and convenience. If you are not sure which are the better options, be it replace your garage door opener or repair the garage door opener motor, it’s best to call a professional. A professional garage door repair company like Spectrum Overhead Door  can give you a free diagnosis of the problem and help you decide which is best for you.


Meet the owner and office staff, and learn how “value” is one of the most important pillars of our company.

Meet Our Staff and Garage Door Technicians




Travis grew up in the Northwest, enjoying fishing with his dad and playing sports with his brother and neighborhood friends. He has enjoyed singing, writing songs, and playing the trumpet for his local church. In high school he excelled at playing…                                            [Repair Techs Contd]



Service Manager

Cory is a Houston native. He is the service manager at Spectrum Overhead Door, and is well known to be a team player. No doubt, he learned some of his great qualities growing up playing soccer, football, and running track. Back then he was known as “Sticks”…                    [Repair Techs Contd]



Parts and Dispatching

Cece has lived in Houston all her life. She has great memories spending time with her father fishing for bass, perch, and catfish. When she was younger she enjoyed competing on a dance team and playing volleyball. Like many of us, Cece was excited to get her…                                       [Repair Techs Contd]



Field Technician

David was born and raised in the Houston area. He enjoyed playing football in high school playing both wide receiver and defensive end. His work experience includes laying tile, general construction, and working at an automotive repair shop. He has…                                      [Repair Techs Contd]



Field Technician

Daniel is both a war veteran and a veteran in the garage door industry. He served his country well, and for many years. He loves chatting with others and will always slip in interesting stories of his past experiences. Daniel is well liked by customers and co-workers…                   [Repair Techs Contd]

You May Also Like…


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Garage Door MaintenanceWhether To Replace Or Repair Your Garage Door Opener